About a month ago I bought a used Macbook 13” for my little sister who is starting college. Earlier this week she called in a panic, on startup all she got was a blinking folder with a question mark and a click sound. I removed the hard drive using the battery bay and plugged it to my PowerBook using an external hard drive bay. My PowerBook wasn’t able to read the hard drive and I concluded that the hard drive was dead.
I then took a brand new hard drive and cloned the data from my PowerBooks using Carbon Copy Cloner and an external hard drive bay. I installed the new-loaded hard drive into the Macbook and nothing. All I got on startup was the startup sound and a gray screen, no pointer, no apple, no flashing question mark, nothing nada!
I then removed the hard drive from my sisters Macbook and installed it in my girlfriend’s MacBook and my girlfriend’s MacBook had no problems it started up perfectly. I also did the opposite installed my girlfriends Hard drive in my sisters computer and I got the same thing (the start up sound and gray screen).
I’ve tried using the C command to boot from the CD and to Target the drive but I get nothing.
Does anyone have any idea what may cause this the problem, the laptop is no longer under warranty and she needs it for school.
Thank you very much for your time.
Last edited by Yannick; Sep 12th, 2008 at 07:49 PM.
I then took a brand new hard drive and cloned the data from my PowerBooks using Carbon Copy Cloner and an external hard drive bay. I installed the new-loaded hard drive into the Macbook and nothing.
That's correct. Powerbooks (and other earlier Macs) format their disks using Apple Partition Table. You cannot boot an Intel Mac from that, the Intels use a different scheme called GUID.
Not sure why you didn't simply put the new drive into the MacBook and use the MacBook's included restore DVD to reformat and install a fresh system/apps onto it, but that's what you need to do. If you've lost the discs that come with it, you'll need to buy a replacement set from Apple (should be just a minimal handling fee).
After doing a restore from the original DVD, be sure to update to the latest version and REPAIR PERMISSIONS before handing it back to your sister. Also, now might be the time to explain to her about backups.
Ill wait for my girlfriend to get home to use her “restore DVD” disc but the only thing I don’t understand is why did the new hard drive booted without any problems when installed on my girlfriend’s laptop but not my sisters.
It makes me think their might be something ease wrong with it...
The trick to eject the CD worked like a charm. I then took the restore DVD and inserted into the drive but when I restarted. It when straight to Chime and then to the gray background, despite me pressing on the C
There's another issue with your MacBook, non-hard drive related. Pull the RAM out and reseat the DIMM's. Potentially an issue with the RAM, logic board or optical drive. (Though not likely the very latter of the those three.)
__________________ ACMT MacBook Pro (15-inch, Mid 2012) 2.3 GHz Core i7, 16GB, 256GB M4 SSD iPhone 8 - 64GB S/G • Sound System Audio Engine A2 • Display UltraSharp U2412M 24" Custom Built Gaming PC Kaby Lake Edition | 16GB DDR4 | GTX 1070 8G